HRSINGAPORE Community Digest
Non-Competition Clauses in Employment Contracts
With the economic downturn dawning on us, some may want to secure financial stability by working for competitors in the same industry for a higher pay.
For competitive industries, the departure of an employee to the competitor may spell a loss of profits and clients, especially in sales-related jobs.
Companies may, as a consequence, attempt to protect themselves by including Non-Compete clauses in Employment Contracts, such as restricting employees from working for competitor’s firm within a year of resignation.
Much discussion in the HR Community has led HR Practitioners to the consensus that although the clause is mutually agreed by both employee and employer, it will be difficult to enforce for the following reasons. Firstly, most HR Practitioners agree that employees who resign to join the competitors cannot be sued for a breach of contract as the law takes into account the livelihood of the employee. Should a company want to sue the ex-employee for a breach of contract, there will be a need to prove that the company’s legitimate interests have been compromised.
Firstly, most HR Practitioners agree that employees who resign to join the competitors cannot be sued for a breach of contract as the law takes into account the livelihood of the employee. Should a company want to sue the ex-employee for a breach of contract, there will be a need to prove that the company’s legitimate interests have been compromised.
Secondly, it will be difficult to prove that an employee has divulged sensitive information or trade secrets which compromised their previous employer.
And thirdly, a competitor or the competition may be too vague to be accurately defined. For instance, would a sales executive for a newspaper who resigns and joins an advertising agency be moving to a competitor?
When including or drafting such clauses into employment contracts, HR Practitioners have suggested five points to take note of:
- Protecting Legitimate Interests (trade secrets / confidential information, nature of work, industry)
- Employee’s Position in the company (higher appointment holders have access to more confidential stuff)
- Geographical Restrictive Covenants (definition of “competition”)
- Period of Restraint (too long a duration may not be allowed in law)
- Where to include the Non-Competition Clause (Employment or Termination)
They also agreed that such clauses may serve as a deterrent even if it will be onerous to legally bind the employee to it.
A broader view of the issue has also been advocated by HR people i.e. look internally and review the organisations reward schemes and strategies for measures to improve retention. Alternatively, promote the bonding of employees to make them more loyal.